I always thought it was odd to hear flat out declarations that there can be no life on other planets in the absence of water. How egocentric! So you’re saying that life can only exist if it’s precisely like us?
That’s the feeling I’m getting right now in the woe-is-us, hand-wringing sob-fest about whether life and our democracy can survive the death of some newspapers.
With all due respect to some great newspapers where I’ve worked, I don’t give a damn about the paper they’re printed on.
What I care about is journalism.
And you don’t need special 3-D glasses to see that completely fabulous, raise the rafters, award-winning, democracy-preserving journalism is being committed and published many times a day in life forms other than newspapers.
Guess what else?
Some online news operations, including two where I was a top manager, have been profitable for years, while upholding the highest standards of journalism.
Here’s a bit of what I saw from an editor’s perch:
- TheStreet.com Silicon Valley reporter Adam Lashinsky’s coverage of the two-tier IPO disclosure practices by investment bankers in 2000 led to Reg FD, the SEC regulation aimed at leveling the information playing field for all investors.
- TSC’s intrepid senior financial columnist, Herb Greenberg, gave shareholders and regulators got an early heads up on the extraordinary accounting fraud at Tyco.
- Had it not been for TSC reporter Adam Feuerstein’s dogged coverage of the biotech firm, ImClone, we wouldn’t have had such a rich lesson from Martha Stewart in what happens when you sell stock and don’t tell the truth.
- Then on Sept. 11, 2001, TSC columnists wrote some of the first online news, blogs and context about the tragedy, even as one of our own died in the North Tower.
Were we perfect? No.
Was it journalism. You betcha.
For more examples of the kind of journalism that’s been committed outside the world of paper, check out the Online News Association’s awards gallery, whose members range from the BBC News and Frontline to Slate and NewWest.
Fast forward to 2007, when the San Diego public radio station, KPBS, performed an amazing public service by using Twitter and a Google maps mashup on its Website to broadcast alerts and illustrate the danger during the deadly wildfires that swept Southern California.
Then in 2008, there was Josh Marshall’s unflinching journalism at Talking Points Memo, which prompted the resignation of the Attorney General of the United States.
Don’t get hung up on the life form: TPM is published with blog technology, and I get updates thrown on my browser’s front lawn by Twitter via RSS, (thank you Dave W!).
Update: And anyone who didn’t see Marcy Wheeler’s breathtakingly good journalism from the blog Emptywheel quoted on the front page of the New York Times, well check out the story right here.
That’s the kind of journalism that helps me sleep well at night.
I spent the first 20 years of my career inside print newsrooms, and I have nothing but admiration for the print folks whose journalism has made the world a better place. (Check out the winners and finalists for the Pulitzer Prize in Public Service Journalism. I’m proud to be on that list, in the company of a team of reporters from the late, great, Dallas Times Herald.)
It is precisely out of respect for those journalistic achievements that I will not lament the demise of newspapers that ignore the public good. David Simon details such a case in this chilling piece in the Washington Post. I’ve also written about instances where having a monopoly on the newspaper market turned watchdogs into sycophantic, naval-gazing, paper tigers. Those newspapers – and the corporations that own them – deserve to decompose with the fish.
But those forces no longer control the conversation – if they ever did. This is spring again, a time for celebration.
Centuries ago, the discovery of movable type meant that Martin Luther no longer needed permission from the Pope to publish his work.
And today, our ideas, conversations and questions won’t be stifled when the newspaper owners run out of cash and ink and stop their giant presses.
We control our own free presses with funny names, like Drupal and Joomla and WordPress, YouTube and Blip and Twitter, Flickr and Utterli and Ning.
And yes, Virginia, there really is a healthy and irrepressible thing called journalism.
Update: Please forgive my unintentional sins of omission and add the following to the list of great un-paper journalism: Politico, The Huffington Post, MarketWatch, Pegasus News and Voice of San Diego.
I will gladly add more as folks knock the cobwebs from my brain!